Bill Gates once remarked that “we all need people who give us feedback. This is how we improve”. But this isn’t always true. Some people get really high quality feedback and yet they still fail to progress. Why is this the case?
The Sutton Trust report that if it is done right, feedback can be one of the most effective ways to help someone improve their learning; however, research suggests that 38% of feedback interventions actually do more harm than goo
The feedback process
The feedback process can be divided into three parts: Asking, Giving and Receiving.
We have previously blogged about the common mistakes people make when they ask for feedback. These include leaving it to the last minute, only asking ‘either-or’ questions and not being fully present in the moment.
This was followed up by our blog on the best ways to give some feedback. These include being specific, avoiding lavish praise and providing clear action steps. This brings us on to the final stage of the process, how to receive feedback.
So much emphasis is usually placed on the person giving the feedback. It is important to know how to give good feedback to students, but the receiver has to take on responsibility as well. Failure to do so will result in a lack of learning and improvement, resulting in mistakes being repeated and lessons not being learnt.
How to receive feedback effectively
So what advice can we give? How can we help people learn to receive feedback better?
The feedback you are being given might be right and might help you. Countless learning opportunities are lost by people entering the situation with a very fixed and closed mind. Being open to possibilities and difference of opinions is a good launch pad for learning.
Distinguish between the message and the messenger
It is important to separate your feelings about who is giving you the feedback from the message that they are actually delivering. Just because you like someone doesn’t mean their feedback is helpful. Likewise, just because you dislike them doesn’t mean the feedback is redundant. Focus on the point, not the person.
It is not a judgement
The feedback you are being given is not a judgement on your personality or on your future ability. See it for what it is, which is advice on how to get a bit better. This is one of the cornerstones that growth mindset theory is built on. Once you start to see feedback on a task as a judgement on our self-identity, it can lead to rejecting the feedback and lead to a fear of failure.
There is a titanic difference between listening intently and being silent whilst preparing a reply. By focusing more on your reply, you are disregarding some of the feedback. If you have asked someone for feedback, and if they have taken the time to offer you advice, you should maximise your time with them by listening carefully.
Check for understanding
The person giving you the feedback may think they have been very clear on what they have said. You may be pretty sure you have understood them. However, it is easy for misunderstanding and miscommunication to occur. Asking them one or two questions to check for understanding may take 1 minute longer, but can save you much more time in the long run.
Take a deep breath
This gives yourself time to process the feedback before reacting. This can really help, especially if things are tense or you feel under pressure. Chances are, your emotional response is unlikely to the best one and you don’t want to make a permanent decision off a temporary feeling.
Focus on what you have learnt
Feedback that doesn’t result in anything changing is as effective as not having received any feedback at all. Asking yourself ‘what would I do differently next time?’ is a great way to ensure you have learnt something. Check out our blog about the 9 best questions to improve metacognition.
Say thank you
Even if you don’t agree with the feedback on this occasion, you may want more later. And it’s just good manners.